Critical global scientific research to take a hit if US bill is passed, warn analysts
Recent measures against Chinese students by some US lawmakers are exacerbating an already hostile environment for these students — which education experts warn could undermine the US' technological leadership and global research collaborations.
A group of House Republicans recently introduced a bill that would bar Chinese nationals from receiving all types of student visas to the US, citing "national security" concerns.
This controversial proposal comes amid increasing scrutiny of Chinese students. The House Select Committee on China has also demanded detailed information regarding Chinese students from Stanford University, the University of Southern California, and several others.
READ MORE: US urged to refrain from harming the rights of Chinese students
These universities must provide data by April 1 on faculty collaborations with Chinese institutions, research projects involving Chinese students, and screening processes for Chinese applicants to "sensitive "research programs.
The proposal alone will dampen Chinese students' sentiments and hurt the US-China research collaboration, according to Eddie West, assistant vice-president for international affairs at California State University, Fresno.
West told China Daily the unpredictability of Washington could make families wonder whether the bill might become law and disrupt their studies. "I doubt the bill will become law, and I feel I have a good enough understanding of the political landscape in the US to make that reasoned judgment call," he said.
Chinese students have long played an important role as a source of science, technology, engineering, and mathematics talent in the US.China is the largest country of origin for US foreign STEM students and provides the most STEM PhD candidates to US universities.
At the graduate level, Chinese students comprise 37 percent of international students and 16 percent of all US students in STEM fields, according to a 2020 study by the Center for Security and Emerging Technology.
The US tech industry heavily relies on this talent pool. Nearly 70 percent of Silicon Valley's tech talent — those with a bachelor's degree or higher in technical occupations — are foreign-born, with 18 percent coming from China, according to data released by the think tank Joint Venture Silicon Valley this month.
Hostile policies
However, the number of Chinese students in the US has been decreasing, from a peak of about 370,000 in 2019 to around 277,398 in the 2023-24 academic year. This decline follows policies implemented during US President Donald Trump's first term when student visas for Chinese applicants were tightened in certain programs, particularly those involving "sensitive" technologies.
Trump's Presidential Proclamation 10043 in May 2020 canceled more than 1,000 visas held by Chinese graduate students and researchers. The Center for Security and Emerging Technology estimates that 3,000 to 5,000 Chinese students are blocked annually by it, which remains in effect.
When faced with such hostile policies, students are likely to turn to other countries as alternative study destinations, West said.
West said some students have already informed his university that they're reconsidering or changing their plans to study in the US given the current climate in the country.
Similar concerns are being voiced by other educators. Piali Sengupta, a biologist at Brandeis University, said on the social media platform Bluesky that she had advised an "excellent postdoc candidate from China" to look at labs in Europe or Asia instead.
"Leaving aside the death spiral of science funding and free speech here, hard to recommend coming here on a visa right now. Tragic to lose talent," she wrote in a post following the introduction of the bill.
ALSO READ: US visas for Chinese students: Concerns on unfair treatment remain
Eloise Dray, assistant professor in the Department of Biochemistry and Structural Biology at the University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio, expressed her frustration about recruiting a "very talented young" doctor of medicine from China to her PhD program, only to face curbs.
"He would have had a mini scholarship from his government, but mostly paid by the lab. Was told that it is forbidden in Texas. I don't think it's the best time to recruit overseas…," she posted on Bluesky.
The restrictions and unwelcoming environment "does a huge disservice to the importance of collaboration "between the US and China, potentially undermining critical global research addressing shared challenges, West said. "The world needs Chinese and US scientists to cooperate, and one of the single best ways to foster that cooperation is through Chinese students and scholars studying and conducting research in the US — as well as US students and scholars studying and conducting research in China."
